Free Trial

MNI EXCLUSIVE: Partial Trade Deal Less Likely: China Advisors

--US Xinjiang Moves Have Made Deal More Difficult, Advisors Say
--Beijing Keen To Limit Dispute To Trade Issues
     BEIJING (MNI) - The chances of a partial deal between China and the U.S.
have fallen significantly following Washington's latest moves to target Chinese
companies and officials, Chinese policy advisors and trade experts told MNI,
with one adding that Beijing is increasingly focussing on ensuring that what it
sees as a long-term dispute does not escalate.
     While some advisors thought there was still a possibility of an interim
agreement, they pointed to this week's U.S. move to add 28 companies and
organization to a blacklist and place visa restrictions on Chinese officials in
response to a "repressive campaign" in Xinjiang. President Donald Trump said
talks with China could be impacted should anything "bad" happen in the handling
of anti-government protests in Hong Kong.
     "China has insisted on the need to separate trade from other issues ... but
(recent U.S. moves) will increase mutual distrust," said Zhou Xiaoming, who
served at China's Mission to the United Nations Office in Geneva, describing the
chances of ever reaching a comprehensive resolution to the trade dispute as
"mission impossible" unless the U.S drops its determination to change China's
economic model.
     There is still a possibility of a partial deal, Zhou said, in which the
U.S. pulls back from a further increase in tariffs on Chinese goods Oct. 15 or
even commits to imposing no new additional levies, in return for Chinese
promises to import more farm and fuel products as well as further moves on
intellectual property rights, technology transfer, and market access. But
Chinese negotiators could also come home with "empty hands".
     Vice Premier and top trade negotiator Liu He is in Washington for a 13th
negotiation round, as talks resume after a suspension of more than two months.
     --TALKS ON YUAN?
     The presence of People's Bank of China Governor Yi Gang in the delegation
may indicate talks include currency and opening access to the financial sector,
a source with knowledge of trade issues said. Taxation and industrial policy may
also be discussed, the source said, noting that fiscal ministry, commerce
ministry, information technology ministry and the agriculture ministry officials
were also present.
     But there is only a "5% chance" of a partial deal, said Wang Haifeng,
director of International Trade and Investment at the Chinese Academy of
Macroeconomic Research. He expected no "obvious progress" on China's industrial
policy or financial sector.
     "Negotiators may explain China's subsidy policy is consistent with
international rules, and address the roadmap and timetable of opening the
financial sector," said Wang, adding that any breakthrough would be closely
linked to whether the U.S. pulls from back from increasing tariffs to 30% from
25% on $250 billion of Chinese goods on Oct. 15.
     Beijing still has room for promises on purchases of U.S. farm products, if
given a few years to meet any such commitment, the source familiar with trade
issues said.
     "If the Trump government is pragmatic and willing to solve problems, it
should give us time. We cannot settle matters in one step," the source said.
"What is done regarding the additional tariffs on Oct. 15 will be key to gauging
whether talks have made any substantial progress."
     The South China Morning Post reported preliminary negotiations have failed
to progress on key issues and that China refused to talk about forced technology
transfers. But the source told MNI China had made efforts to address this issue,
together with providing more protection for intellectual property rights and
opening up its markets, through measures including the upcoming Foreign
Investment Law.
     --LONG-TERM PESSIMISM
     In the longer term, the source was pessimistic the U.S. would agree to roll
back tariffs imposed since the dispute began last year, although he noted that
Trump and China's President Xi Jinping had the power to strike an agreement.
     "It is up to the two top leaders whether they want a deal or not," the
source said, noting that Beijing will try to ensure the dispute remains
contained within negotiations and does not spiral into confrontation.
     He Weiwen, senior fellow at Renmin University's Chongyang Institute for
Financial Studies, said China will insist on the removal of all tariffs imposed
since last year. Trump will regard targetting China as electorally advantageous,
and will not cede ground, said He, former counsellor at the Chinese Consulates
General in New York and San Francisco, and China will not abandon its economic
model.
     Zhou Mi, senior fellow at the Chinese Academy of International Trade and
International Trade and Economic Cooperation, a Ministry of Commerce think tank,
told MNI only a comprehensive deal would serve Beijing's interests.
--MNI London Bureau; +44 203 865 3829; email: jason.webb@marketnews.com
[TOPICS: M$A$$$,M$Q$$$,M$U$$$,MC$$$$,MI$$$$,MT$$$$,MX$$$$,MGQ$$$,MGU$$$]

To read the full story

Close

Why MNI

MNI is the leading provider

of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.

Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.