Free Trial

MNI SOURCES: Italian Panetta Seen Taking ECB Market Role

--Fabio Panetta Seen As Likely To Take ECB Market Role, Officials Said
--Policy Review May Focus On Inflation Target
--Next Few Months' Data Seen Supporting Unchanged Policy
     LONDON (MNI) - Italian Fabio Panetta may take over management of the
European Central Bank's key market operations brief as new president Christine
Lagarde oversees an Executive Board overhaul ahead of a review of the ECB's
monetary policy framework, ECB officials told MNI.
     Panetta and German Isabel Schnabel would fit naturally into the roles taken
by their Executive Board predecessors Benoit Coure and Sabine Lautenschlaeger
once they arrive at the ECB around the turn of the year, several sources said.
The reshuffle, to be decided by Lagarde, would come as she faces calls from some
within the broader Governing Council to make the monetary policy process more
democratic now that former President Mario Draghi has left.
     "I'd suggest Mr Panetta will fill the role vacated by Benoit Coeure, while
Isabel Schnabel will fit nicely into the vacated banking role," said one
official, asking not to be named.
     Another official said: "There will not be a big public discussion. Lagarde
will probably reflect over Christmas and then there will be an Executive Board
discussion in January."
     Lautenschlaeger was given responsibility for overseeing banknotes, market
infrastructure, risk management and payment systems in April, when her term as
deputy chair of the supervisory board of the Single Supervisory Mechanism came
to an end. Yves Mersch has been named as the SSM board's deputy chair, but
Schnabel could assume that role too once Mersch leaves the ECB at the end of
next year, another official said.
     --GOVERNING COUNCIL DISSENT
     Lagarde, who presides over her first meeting on Dec. 12, will face a
Governing Council riven by unusual levels of disagreement following September's
easing package, which prompted open expressions of dissent from Dutch and German
central bankers and was followed by Lautenschlaeger's resignation.
     Draghi, who irritated some colleagues by pre-announcing policy measures
before they had been agreed, tended to ram through decisions he favoured without
votes, officials said. ECB rules already permit Governing Council members to
initiate votes, but, in practice, sources said, these had not taken place.
     "The fact that votes aren't counted within the Governing Council has
created tensions and many think it should be otherwise. That is something which
will need be addressed sooner or later," one official said.
     But another official said moving towards greater transparency by publishing
more complete accounts revealing individual Council members' opinions would be
impractical.
     Lagarde has already indicated support for a review of the ECB's monetary
policy framework, something called for by Finland's Olli Rehn. A similar
exercise is underway at the Federal Reserve, and the Bank of Canada carries them
out periodically.
     "I think they will try to mimic the Canadian or Fed exercises. My opinion
is that that final outcome will be to make this 2% metric more credible in some
way," said one official, referring to the ECB's inflation target.
     Another official said the review would start with "a fairly blank sheet."
     --INFLATION TARGET
     "The inflation target option could be to ... move to a more realistic
target band, for example the RBA has 2% to 3%, the BOE targets 2% but has
greater discretion of 1 percentage point either side."
     Another official, though, was cautious about likely changes resulting from
the review, which could start early next year.
     "We're still stuck in the same scenario," the official said, "So we need
some kind of change, to exit this phase, before we can start discussing a new
approach."
     The prospects for further immediate policy clashes may be reduced by what
appears to be a stabilising economy, with signs that risks such as the
China-U.S. trade dispute and a hard Brexit may recede for the time being. Any
concerns within the Governing Council regarding ongoing policy, such as the
difficulty of keeping quantitative easing asset purchases in line with the
so-called "capital key", will likely be kept inhouse for the near future at
least, one official said.
     "It's going to be a pretty quiet period for a few months at least. Data
will bump along at lower levels without any great deterioration and I suppose
for a change there could be signs of upside risk," another source said, adding
that any economic improvement might have the unfortunate side effect of reducing
the likelihood eurozone governments will heed ECB calls for greater fiscal
stimulus.
     "We're all on board in supporting a more accommodative stance, but some
would rather wait to see a very serious deterioration of the outlook before
weighing any other options," another official said.
     "I think there will be a debate on what 'severe deterioration' really
means. The risk is that while we debate, we might end up behind the curve with
inflation expectations already de-anchoring."
--MNI London Bureau; +44 203 865 3829; email: jason.webb@marketnews.com
[TOPICS: M$X$$$,MT$$$$,MX$$$$,M$$EC$]

To read the full story

Close

Why MNI

MNI is the leading provider

of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.

Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.