Free Trial

BREXIT: EU Says 'No Decisive Progress', Divorce Bill Disputed

--No Big Declarations From Brexit Talks
--UK Disputes Legal Basis For Bill
--Davis Accuses EU Of Putting Process Before People
By Tara Oakes
     BRUSSELS (MNI) - Frustrated EU Chief Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier
Thursday presented a gloomy prognosis of the third round of Brexit talks.
     "No decisive progress has been made on key issues," Barnier told
journalists in Brussels at a joint press conference with his UK counterpart,
David Davis.
     The assessment was damning but not unexpected, after rumblings of
discontent from the EU side on Britain's approach negotiations have intensified
over the week.
     Markets as well as the weary press mob had foreseen Barnier's comments,
with a distinct lack of movement in both the pound's level against the euro and
in UK Gilt yields noted after the briefing.
     DIVORCE BILL
     Settling the accounts between Britain and the EU remains the most
contentious issue, with the UK refuting the EU's assessment with a
"line-by-line" legal analysis provided by their own lawyers, rather than
publishing a rival position paper.
     An EU official familiar with the negotiations said the EU rejected the UK's
lengthy refutation.
     "They say basically that the last financial obligation to which they feel
legally bound will be the last payment they make to the EU budget as a member
state," the source said.
     The EU believe that obligation to pay stems from the 7-year rolling
Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) and the Own Resource Decision (ORD), which
the UK signed up to when still a member.
     But after a press conference where Davis said the UK recognised they have
"moral" as well as legal obligations to pay, the source said the EU side
remained perplexed that the whole presentation amounted to nothing more than "a
default legal view" relevant in case of no agreement, rather than a proposal for
the financial settlement "as such".
     Barnier, claiming that he had the "calm of a mountaineer" and denying that
he was angry at the disappointing results, slammed some of the UK's much-touted
"flexibility".
     "The UK wants to take back control and adopt its own standards and
regulations, but also wants to have standards recognised automatically by the
European Union," Barnier said.
     "This is simply impossible, to be outside the single market and shape its
legal order," he told journalists.
     TIME TICKING
     Barnier repeated his reminder that time is flying by for negotiations,
which the EU are adamant have to reach "sufficient progress" on separation
issues by October for any future relationship to be discussed.
     Davis and his team have been badgering their EU counterparts to untie
themselves from this stringent timetable, but there is as of yet no give.
     "The mandate means very clear, precise sequencing," Barnier said.
     Davis jibed in his opening remarks that it was time to "put people above
process".
     Rounds of talks may become more frequent in the run-up to October, with
Barnier saying the EU team were ready to "step up and intensify" negotiations.
The UK side are believed to be open to the suggestion, but with party
conferences looming Davis might be occupied with domestic Tory infighting in the
coming weeks.
     LIMITED PROGRESS
     Both Davis and Barnier hailed some small areas of progress, including
protecting the rights of frontier workers.
     Agreement was also reached on the cross-border medical European Health
Insurance (EHIC) card, Davis said - a previous sticking point in talks.
     According to the "grid" published after talks detailing areas of contention
in green, amber or red, both sides have agreed that UK residents in an EU member
state at the moment of withdrawal - March 29, 2019 at midnight - will be able to
continue benefitting from the EU-wide EHIC scheme in their country of residence
and in any EU27 country they go to on holiday.
     But if they choose to move to another EU member state, they would lose that
right, according to the present state of negotiations. It is understood that the
UK side are pushing for a greater extension of this so UK citizens residing in
Britain could also continue benefitting from their EHICs, but there is as of yet
no agreement from the EU side.
     Those who possess professional qualifications -- doctors, lawyers,
architects and more - will be able to continue to have them recognised in the UK
or their member state of residence at the level they currently enjoy if they
reside in an EU27 country on Brexit day, according to the negotiation document.
If they do not, there is no agreement yet on reciprocal future recognition.
     UK negotiators are believed to be pushing for this too to be extended so,
for example, EU national students studying to be doctors at UK universities can
have the confidence that their qualifications will be worth something back home
by the time they graduate.
     Even if the sticking points are mended, the deal will also have to be
approved by the European Parliament before it comes into force.
--MNI Brussels Bureau; +44 203-865-3851; email: tara.oakes@marketnews.com
--MNI Paris Bureau; tel: +33 1-42-71-55-41; email: jack.duffy@marketnews.com
[TOPICS: M$B$$$,M$E$$$,MC$$$$,MFB$$$,MGB$$$]

To read the full story

Close

Why MNI

MNI is the leading provider

of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.

Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.