-
Policy
Policy
Exclusive interviews with leading policymakers that convey the true policy message that impacts markets.
LATEST FROM POLICY: -
EM Policy
EM Policy
Exclusive interviews with leading policymakers that convey the true policy message that impacts markets.
LATEST FROM EM POLICY: -
G10 Markets
G10 Markets
Real-time insight on key fixed income and fx markets.
Launch MNI PodcastsFixed IncomeFI Markets AnalysisCentral Bank PreviewsFI PiFixed Income Technical AnalysisUS$ Credit Supply PipelineGilt Week AheadGlobal IssuanceEurozoneUKUSDeep DiveGlobal Issuance CalendarsEZ/UK Bond Auction CalendarEZ/UK T-bill Auction CalendarUS Treasury Auction CalendarPolitical RiskMNI Political Risk AnalysisMNI Political Risk - US Daily BriefMNI Political Risk - The week AheadElection Previews -
Emerging Markets
Emerging Markets
Real-time insight of emerging markets in CEMEA, Asia and LatAm region
-
Commodities
-
Credit
Credit
Real time insight of credit markets
-
Data
-
Global Macro
Global Macro
Actionable insight on monetary policy, balance sheet and inflation with focus on global issuance. Analysis on key political risk impacting the global markets.
Global MacroDM Central Bank PreviewsDM Central Bank ReviewsEM Central Bank PreviewsEM Central Bank ReviewsBalance Sheet AnalysisData AnalysisEurozone DataUK DataUS DataAPAC DataInflation InsightEmployment InsightGlobal IssuanceEurozoneUKUSDeep DiveGlobal Issuance Calendars EZ/UK Bond Auction Calendar EZ/UK T-bill Auction Calendar US Treasury Auction Calendar Global Macro Weekly -
About Us
To read the full story
Sign up now for free trial access to this content.
Please enter your details below.
Why MNI
MNI is the leading provider
of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.
Real-time Actionable Insight
Get the latest on Central Bank Policy and FX & FI Markets to help inform both your strategic and tactical decision-making.
Free AccessInsight: BOE Can't Re-use 'Murky' Guidance To Shift Markets
By David Robinson
LONDON (MNI) - The Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee's attempt to
get financial markets to price-in more tightening fell flat at its August
meeting and the debate is open over how to make its messaging more effective in
coming months.
MNI spoke to market participants, analysts and people familiar with the
Bank's thinking. There was agreement that the imprecise message the MPC
delivered in August had been very hard for markets to re-act to but the catch is
that with the committee split over the need for near-term tightening it will be
challenging for it to come up with anything more specific at its upcoming
meetings.
At the August meeting the MPC voted six-to-two in favour of unchanged
policy and offered no agreed line on near-term tightening and the accompanying
Inflation Report forecasts for growth and inflation were little changed. Around
a third of analysts had predicted three votes in support of a hike, and the
initial market response, part-driven by algorithmic trades, was to treat the
news as relatively dovish and to push sterling and yield curves lower.
The minutes, however, contained a line that markets had been under-pricing
the amount of tightening required, stating that if things evolved as forecast
"then monetary policy could need to be tightened by a somewhat greater extent
over the forecast period than the path implied by the yield curve underlying the
August projections."
"Algos will respond to the outcome and minutes vote first. There was a
genuine need to price out the possibility of a hike at that meeting. What the
MPC said was never going to be enough to deliver a hawkish response. They said
they needed more tightening but didn't do what was necessary to see it
priced-in," Philip Rush, of economic consultancy Heteronomics, said.
The esoteric approach to central bank guidance is to classify it as Delphic
or Odyssean. As ECB Executive Board member Benoit Coeure set it out in a speech
in March. Delphic guidance relies on the central bank forecast of how the
economy will likely evolve, while Odyssean guidance "relates what we think will
happen to what we will do if it happens."
The MPC's August line on the likelihood that the market was under-pricing
tightening is "a bit of both. The Delphic bit is 'if the world turns out how we
think it will, then our future behaviour, which we want to reveal/clarify, means
that interest rates will follow a path like x.' The Odyssean bit is that once
this promise has been made, there will be a cost to pay if rates don't follow
x," said Tony Yates, an academic and formerly a senior figure in the BOE's
directorate devoted to monetary policy.
The frustration for traders who were looking for anything supportive of
tightening was the statement's lack of specificity about when and by how much
Bank Rate might need to rise. As one strategist noted, with nothing offered on
near-term tightening it was an impossible task on the day to decide where to try
and push yield curves higher.
"Although the MPC doesn't have the job of making trades easy, I sympathise,
since there is no good reason ... why this more specific guidance should not be
given," Yates said.
Yates said that "in general the context is one in which MPC announcements
are unnecessarily murky."
Unlike the US Federal Reserve, the BOE has decided against providing
individual interest rate forecasts for voting members.
Instead the Inflation Report forecasts are the best collective judgement of
the MPC, essentially whichever forecast they can sign-off, based on market
rates. After signing-off on the quarterly forecasts, members thrash out a form
of words for the Monetary Policy Summary part of the minutes.
Ahead of the publication on August 3 of the minutes and policy decision,
markets were focussed on the vote, with opinions split over whether BOE Chief
Economist Andrew Haldane would join Ian McCafferty and Michael Saunders, in
backing a hike and whether the MPC would say something concrete on the
likelihood in coming months of raising Bank Rate.
The initial wire headlines and BOE twitter feed announced the unchanged
policy decision and revealed that there were only two votes for a hike. The
BOE's website froze as the midday announcement came through, with any economists
and strategists who were looking to access the detailed text of the policy
statement temporarily blindsided.
At the subsequent press conference, to the annoyance of traders looking for
a hawkish line, BOE Governor Mark Carney ducked saying anything of substance on
the likely timing of the first hike.
Asked if thought that "the curve is currently underestimating the timing of
the first hike" Carney replied "I don't think it's appropriate for me to tie the
hands of the Committee by expanding on our view as a Committee, particularly
with respect to timing."
One problem for Carney and his colleagues is that with the MPC split over
the need for near-term tightening, agreeing any specific guidance is knotty.
Among the issues the committee members weigh is whether the costs of hiking too
early are greater than hiking too late, how substantial the cost of a policy
reversal would be and what the credibility cost would be of once again raising
the possibility of a near-term hike only to pull back.
Gertjan Vlieghe is one MPC member who is very wary of hiking near-term,
saying in an interview with the Independent published July 3 that "this is an
environment where a premature hike would be a bigger mistake than one that turns
out to be slightly late because of the asymmetry around risk."
Silvana Tenreyro only attended her first meeting in August. It would be
understandable if she wants time before signing up to guidance on a near-term
hike.
Carney himself faces concerns about credibility problem as his previous,
albeit explicitly conditional, steers on when a rate hike could come have never
resulted in any actual tightening.
At the MPC's next meeting, decision expected September 14, and at the
subsequent November one, Carney and his colleagues will again have to decide if
they want to try and agree on a more effective steer to markets than in August.
The most straightforward option to push market rate expectations higher
would be for one, or more, further members to vote for a hike as agreement on
any more specific guidance may prove elusive. With the data showing that while
inflation is running above target the economy is slowing and pay growth is
subdued, MPC members are unlikely to be queuing up to take the plunge and vote
for a hike.
Whether the MPC choses to repeat its August line that "monetary policy
could need to be tightened by a somewhat greater extent over the forecast period
than the path implied by the yield curve," would be a sideshow unless there
something more concrete to flesh it out.
More trivially, the Bank is set to upgrade its website, with the new
version hopefully immune to freezing - which would at least allow analysts to
study whatever words the MPC does agree on straight after the policy
announcement is made.
The first 25 Bank Rate hike, lifting it from 0.25% to 0.5%, is only fully
priced-in on OIS rates in around 24 months' time, later than before the
Inflation Report was released and with the curve rising at only a glacial pace
from there. If the MPC had hoped to drive the curve higher, its communication in
August appears to have failed to do the job.
--MNI London Bureau; tel: +44 203-586-2225; email: les.commons@marketnews.com
--MNI London Bureau; tel: +44 203-586-2223; email: david.robinson@marketnews.com
[TOPICS: M$B$$$,M$E$$$,MX$$$$,M$$BE$]
To read the full story
Sign up now for free trial access to this content.
Please enter your details below.
Why MNI
MNI is the leading provider
of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.