Free Trial

MNI ANALYSIS: Keep Calm And Vote Merkel Stance Winning For CDU

MNI (London)
--Latest Polls Suggest Germany Set To Give Chancellor Fourth Term
--Still Unclear Which Parties Will Form Governing Coalition
By Tara Oakes
     LONDON (MNI) - Untroubled by rhetoric by fire or fury, a German woman
relaxes, eyes closed in a flourishing field. "Enjoy the summer now -- and make
the right choice in autumn," the slogan suggests with hazy insouciance. Above,
the letters of German Chancellor Angela Merkel's CDU party float, unobtrusive to
the rays of the August sun.
     Pollsters and think tanks are proving that this softly-softly tactic is
paying off big time for the centre-right CDU/CSU team, who are riding high with
38% of the projected vote in figures released Saturday by Emnid.
     Merkel, the party's figurehead and Chancellor since 2005, gave her first
full campaign speech in Dortmund Saturday with little indication that she would
stray from the party line of promising electors more of the same.
     The message is winning and Merkel looks set to coast to the largest
proportion of seats in the Bundestag on September 24 - the question now is just
who will prop up her government.
     SPD
     Current coalition partners the centre-left SPD have been burned by their
experience as the junior partner in a 'grand coalition'. Chancellor candidate
Martin Schulz, former head of the European Parliament, has tried to bring the
fight to Merkel with little avail -- trailing 14 points behind at 24%, according
to the same poll.
     "It's a very difficult campaign, because it's a problem that Merkel has no
campaign at the moment," SPD MEP Joachim Schuster told MNI.
     Schulz's failure to set an aggressive campaign agenda can partly be
attributed to the season, with little appetite among voters for disruptive
summer politicking. But the wider trend appears to be an acceptance that when
times are good, there's no need to rock the boat.
     Schuster said that the SPD had to push public awareness of their own part
in setting up those good times, rather than letting the relative silence of
Merkel's campaign tacitly grant her all the credit.
     For Schuster, another 'grand coalition' should only be toyed with if the
SPD were the bigger partner.
     "If we are not successful and the Christian Democrats win the election, I
am against a new coalition. It's impossible after the last years that we will
always be the junior partner," he told MNI.
     FDP
     It may yet be that the SPD aren't even asked to consider coalition talks --
September's vote is likely to herald the return of the liberal FDP to the
parliament after their shock failure to meet the minimum threshold last vote.
     The FDP, pulling 8% in the poll, are closer ideologically to the CDU and
have long been their favoured coalition partners.
     But the party had learnt from its mistakes of too closely aligning
themselves with the CDU, FDP MEP Michael Theurer told MNI.
     "Voters could not recognize their own liberal, market-oriented handwriting
of the FDP," Theurer said of the last campaign. The FDP have therefore carved
out a distinctive niche calling for Germany's large economy to "adapt to the
digital challenge", he added.
     "We will not enter into a coalition if we cannot safeguard or guarantee a
change in the political line of the government," Theurer told MNI.
     BRACING FOR THE FUTURE
     FDP proposals to provide incentives for venture capital, cut income tax and
remove red tape for SMEs are one way to address how to arm the German economic
juggernaut for the future. Because if the CDU continues with the same hesitancy
in its economic programme as in its national campaign, risks increase that it
will be ill-equipped to keep up the success in a changing world.
     "There are changes going on internationally, so we cannot just keep on
going and hoping that our exports will be bought throughout the world. We are an
ageing society, we are lacking in digitalization, we have lots of problems with
infrastructure and investment, so we need to have a lot of reform in these
respects," the head of the globalization and world economy programme at
thinktank DGAP, Claudia Schmucker, told MNI.
     Market participants are also raising worries.
     "Relaxed monetary policy is likely to sustain strong economic growth in
Germany for some years to come. But behind the gleaming facade, German economic
competitiveness will continue to falter," Commerzbank warned Friday, suggesting
that Germany could be the next France if another recession hit.
     The SPD want to harness the country's powerful economy for more
infrastructure spending, echoing the desires of France and the EU. But they are
also calling for generous labour market reforms which could push more costs onto
employers.
     Voters' resistance to change hasn't welcomed the comparatively lavish SPD
proposals. It also helped scupper transatlantic trade deal TTIP with the U.S.,
much to Merkel's dismay. For Schmucker, the re-elected chancellor will have to
set out a firmer case for free trade if Germany is to keep profiting from
globalization.
     "After the elections she really needs to do a lot more on trade to convince
the public. She needs to get the French on their side, because Macron is really
similar in trade -- to get both of them together to show that it's not only
Germany, it's Germany and France together," Schmucker told MNI.
     GREENS
     The Green party's rejection of TTIP was certainly in line with the public
mood -- and some have mooted the idea of their joining a so-called 'Jamaica'
coalition with FDP and the CDU/CSU to reach the numbers to govern.
     For Schmucker, this would be a "huge problem" for trade policy, because of
the Green's standard "distrust" of the U.S.
     But Green MEP Sven Giegold pointed out that the Greens already work with
the CDU/CSU in coalitions running four of the German Lande (regions).
     "These governments are always difficult, because from an ideological point
of view of course we are very far apart. On the other hand, we have one
long-running experience with them: that is that once you have a deal, you have a
deal," Giegold told MNI.
     For any coalition deal, the Greens would expect compromises to be offered
in line with their 10-point electoral programme, which includes a call for
emissions-free cars that elsewhere would have won votes after the "Dieselgate"
scandal.
Merkel's Dortmund speech did take in international criticism of the German car
industry, which she accused of eroding trust. But she also rejected Schulz's
pitch for a quota on electric cars on the continent, insisting that petrol and
diesel vehicles were still needed.
     The sprawling car lobby and its influence on politics has been largely
shrugged off in Germany, even after Dieselgate.
     EUROPE
     Much of Europe has anxiously waited for Germany to step up the gas in terms
of the elections, at least -- with key policy areas of closer Economic and
Monetary Union and Greece needing the input of a secure German government, out
of campaign mode.
     With the backing of France, progress could be made to create a Eurozone
finance minister for the bloc.
     "This will come anyway and everybody knows it," Giegold, who has argued in
favour of the position, told MNI, adding that there would be "additional
momentum" after the national vote.
     But all eyes will also be on Germany to grant further debt relief to Greece
-- one of the conditions of the IMF's signing up to the latest disbursement
programme and a deeply unpopular stance with German voters.
     "I think the present parties are really hoping that it will not come up
before the election -- even though the SPD might be softer to that, the public
is opposed," Schmucker said. But eventually, she added, the government would
have to cave to the international pressure on for Greek debt relief.
     "Merkel is a European person and there's a lot of pressure right now to
keep Europe together and to do more about it, so I think eventually she will
give more and she will participate in a deal," Schmucker said.
     With only six weeks until the election, it could all still be to play for
-- but if all goes to plan, the CDU are hoping that they won't have to play at
all.
--MNI London Bureau; tel: +44 203-586-2225; email: les.commons@marketnews.com
[TOPICS: M$E$$$,M$G$$$,M$X$$$,MC$$$$,MX$$$$]
MNI London Bureau | +44 203-865-3812 | les.commons@marketnews.com

To read the full story

Close

Why MNI

MNI is the leading provider

of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.

Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.