Free Trial

MNI: EU/UK Port Trade Growth Risks Severe Brexit Downturn

MNI (London)
By Tara Oakes
     LONDON (MNI) - The growth in container trade between the UK and the
European Union in the last 18 months underlines that ports in both regions face
a sharp slowdown in business if a 'hard' Brexit endangers existing supply chains
and removes the benefits the customs union has allowed their customers to
Figures from the EU's biggest ports show that they have benefitted from a sharp
increase in containerised trade with Britain since the UK's referendum on EU
membership, showing the risks faced if the UK crashes out with no deal or
demands the hardest Brexit are not just on the British side of the Channel.
     Carriers using the ports may be front-loading trade before Brexit hits in
order to take advantage of the current status quo before risking the uncertainty
of Brexit. But at present rates of growth, they are becoming exposed to greater
downside in the case of 'no-deal'.
Statistics from the Port of Hamburg obtained by MNI show a rise in containerized
cargo volumes handled by the port even after the shock referendum result in
2016, when the UK voted to leave the bloc.
Hamburg's containerized trade with the UK rose 6.9% from 2015 to 2016, from 1.3
million to 1.4 million tons. Container volumes also increased 12.6% over the
same period, from 219,000 to 246,000 TEU (twenty-foot equivalent units, the
global measurement for container shipping).
"The positive trend in container traffic continued in the first half of 2017, up
3.6%," a representative from the port of Hamburg told MNI. The UK moved up to
Hamburg's 8th top trading partner in seaborne container traffic in 2016, higher
than its rank of 11th in 2015.
The port warned that the current uncertainty surrounding Brexit negotiations
means that although they are examining the impact of Brexit "in detail", its
impact on their trade could not yet accurately be predicted.
But with the UK's insistence that they will eventually leave the customs union
and the single market as part of any Brexit deal -- even if a temporary
transition period is eventually agreed -- the recent rise in cargo trade with
the UK means a larger proportion of EU ports' business is in jeopardy.
Yves Adriaensen, Head of Market Intelligence at the Port of Antwerp, told MNI
that they were worried about it "severely" hitting their cargo streams. Antwerp
currently deals with about 15 million tons of cargo annually which is
UK-related, as well as 1.4 million tons from the Republic of Ireland.
Like Hamburg, much of Antwerp's UK seaborne cargo trade is containerized.
Adriaensen warned that starker problems would be faced by any of the ports
dealing mainly with roll-on, roll-off (ro-ro) cargo such as Calais or Zeebrugge,
because the transportation of a driver attached to a lorry exposed the ports to
further risks related to free movement of people, as well as free movement of
Calais celebrated the "best quarter in its history" in terms of cross-channel
freight in Q1 2017, posting an 11.2% increase from Q1 2016. Much of this is
roll-on, roll-off.
Zeebrugge has also been pushing its upgraded links to the UK, with P&O launching
a "major expansion" of their Hull-Zeebrugge route in May 2017, including a
Stg8.5mln upgrade of their two ships on the route, which carries tourists and
containers as well as ro-ro.
Ro-ro lorry drivers on both sides of the Brexit dividing lines currently have no
assurance about what their right of movement would be between the UK and EU when
Brexit hits in 2019.
Ports' worries about containerized traffic and free movement of people are due
to a lack of clarity or progress from Brexit talks, the current round of which
have trundled on with no significant progress in Brussels this week.
The figures, which cover the overall UK-related cargo volume handled by ports
including imports and exports, could also be pushed up by a spike in exports
from the UK driven by the drop in the pound, while Europe-origin products are
starting to prove a difficult sell in Britain after the currency drop. 
     Soft data from the UK, including PMIs and the CBI trends survey, indicate a
strong export business.
Trade between Britain and the bloc has likely been spurred by the weaker pound
and data indicates a general trend upwards of EU-UK from 2016-2017, although
data for the latter is still incomplete before year-end.
     Official data from the UK's Office for National Statistics certainly
suggest a pick up in overall EU/UK trade in the first 6 months of 2017 over the
last year, probably helped by both the weaker UK currency and the solid and
continuing economic rebound in the euro area.
Consumers in the UK have also until recently sought to maintain their standard
of living, but as the uncertainty surrounding the future filters through this
may dip -- especially if costs of living rise.
Some Brexit effects are already hitting EU ports off the back of the pound's
drop, stifling the market for European exports, Adriaensen told MNI. Antwerp's
highly developed chemical cluster is suffering due to the fall in the pound, as
UK buyers cannot afford the products that would previously have been shipped
over to them.
"The British pound as opposed to the euro has slumped, and that has an effect on
our trade, especially second half of last year. We also see a continued effect
of that on the first two quarters of this year on our chemical trade," he said,
adding that this had already amounted to a couple of percentage points negative
In the case of a hard Brexit, the hit would be even worse.
"There's a couple of scenarios on the table, but let's assume it's about a 5-10%
decrease of about exports of about 3 million tons on an annual basis of chemical
products -- liquids, that is -- so that's something we're taking into account,"
Adriaensen added.
UK Prime Minister Theresa May publicly announced her desire for a transition
deal in Florence on Friday, but her government's insistence on dropping out of
the customs union and single market has been a constant refrain.
After publishing a report on the likely hit of customs worst case scenarios, the
Institute for Government's Joe Owen told MNI that even if there is a transition,
the longer this takes to hammer out, the more at risk trade with the UK is.
"A transition loses its value the longer it takes to agree because there are
certain organisations who will need to start putting in place contingency plans
for no deal around the end of this year," Owen said.
"It's a sort of canyon rather than a cliff edge that you need to avoid, because
there is this cliff edge on the other side of the channel, and any disruption
felt from either side of the channel will impact both," he added.
The cost to ports cautioned by Institute for Government's report also highlights
that ports would have to factor in the training and infrastructure of new
customs services to deal with the third-country products in the case of a cliff
edge, delaying trade during its installation. 
     The port operators are obviously unwilling to commit to the large cash
outlay if a softer deal is found -- but this means that if it is needed, the
beginning of the process has been continually pushed back while all eyes are on
Without efforts from both sides to mitigate the tidal wave of Brexit, EU ports
are increasingly exposed by their growing trade figures with the UK and risk a
large part of their business being swept away.
--MNI London Bureau; tel: +44 203-586-2225; email:
[TOPICS: M$B$$$,M$E$$$,MC$$$$,MI$$$$]
MNI London Bureau | +44 203-865-3812 |

To read the full story



MNI is the leading provider

of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.

Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.