Free Trial

MNI EXCLUSIVE: Italy Faces Regional Votes For Greater Autonomy

MNI (London)
--Regional Votes Will Underline Political Risks Ahead 2018 Election
By Silvia Marchetti
     ROME (MNI) - As tensions in Catalonia ease just a little, two looming
referenda in Italy appear set to move the regional autonomy debate away from
Spain. The northern regions of Lombardy and Veneto will likely vote for greater
federalism and increased autonomy in certain fields, including the handling of
taxation which is key issue, senior lawmakers have told Market News
International. 
     The two regions will vote on greater autonomy on October 22, risking
increased political tensions and instability ahead of next year's general
election as parties across the spectrum look to define their manifestoes,
looking for "winning" platform themes. 
     Voter turnout is expected to be good and is likely to boost the ratings for
 populist parties.
     Lombardy, Italy's production and financial hub, is a net contributor to
state finances and makes up a big slice of national GDP. Its GDP per capita
(E30,600) makes it the third richest region in the European Union. Populism,
though, is rising: Lombardy is the region with the highest concentration of
refugee camps in Italy, giving pro-reform supporters further valid reason to
battle against Rome. 
     If locals vote 'yes' at the referendum, the outcome would entail
significant falls in tax revenues for the central state, but granting Lombardy a
"fiscal bonus" of roughly E56 billion.  
     Both regions are demanding, if they secure a positive vote outcome, that
90% of taxation stays within their territory. 
     The recent Catalonian independence referendum, despite the uncertain
outcome and current stalemate, has increased confidence in Italy's northern
regions that similar successes will be replicated at home. 
     But regional 'populists' argue their goal is different from the Spanish
case: The Northern League party, several local Democrats and members of the
anti-establishment 5Star movement argue they do not seek independence from Rome,
just greater legislative autonomy.
     "We are simply asking to implement what is already envisaged in the Italian
constitution for specific regions, and despite past failed referenda, we believe
this time we can make it," Senator Massimiliano Fedriga, Northern League party
leader in the Senate told MNI. 
     "We expect a high voter turnout, in sign of protest against former premier
Matteo Renzi's failed constitutional reform attempt aimed at centralizing power
in Rome. Pro-autonomy support is wide-spread among many other parties, it's not
just us spearheading it," said Fedriga.  
     Officials and analysts in Rome fear that the referenda could trigger
political mayhem and raise party tensions ahead of next year's national vote,
giving another hot issue to exploit in an attempt to lure voters. 
     The referenda will also act as a testing ground to measure voter turnout at
next spring's national elections. 
     "It's a very clever political move that falls just at the right moment, in
between the approval of the 2018 budget and a few months before the general
elections," argued Democrat Giampaolo Galli, member of the Lower House Budget
Committee. 
     Lombardy and Veneto both aim to obtain what is already granted by the
constitution to other 5 regions in Italy already enjoying a "special statute"
granting them more powers and autonomy. 
     According to Galli, rising populist stances across Europe are fuelling
"localisms", that are "shifting from nationalisms of nation states built in the
1800's to a greater role of smaller, local communities within the states" that
demand more space to handle taxes as they wish and approve laws, just like
Catalonia in Spain. 
     If the referenda were to pass, the risk is that of "destroying national
solidarity and burden-sharing among regions,", explained Galli, as "all the rich
Italians would end up moving to live in one small area, concentrating their
wealth over there". 
     Another risk is that of giving parties a concrete field on which to fight,
according to Giovanni Orsina, School of Government head at Rome-based LUISS
University.
     "The trouble is, parties are grappling in search of real, sound electoral
themes, and the referenda, depending on voter turnout, could give them a great
battle field. The 'northern/rich' regions issue versus the 'southern/poor' ones
is dormant right now in the pre-electoral campaign debate, but could be woken up
with catastrophic political consequences. A spark that could trigger a fire,"
Orsina said. 
     Polls suggest the referenda are likely to pass with up to 80% of votes in
each region. If so, a long period of negotiations between central government and
the winning regions would start to modify power divisions, which could see
months pass before a decree is issued to regulate the new state/region
relationship. 
     A 'yes' victory could have another major impact -- possibly fracturing the
populist Northern League, however. "Lombardy's governor Roberto Maroni is a
Northern League traditionalist, a hawk. Current party leader Matteo Salvini, a
dove, has kept a lower profile by not cleverly linking the upcoming referenda to
the outcome in Catalonia, argued Orsina.
     "Salvini wants the Northern League, Italy's third-largest party, to be a
nation-wide group and not just restricted to the north. He wants southerners
votes as well, and aims to boost his current 15% poll rating to consolidate his
dominion in the populist front," said Orsina. 
     The uncertain outcome in Catalonia, and the political mayhem triggered by
the independence referendum which result is now being blocked, are pushing
Salvini to adopt a careful stance but "localist" feelings are set to rise in
Italy as the electoral campaign heats up by the day. 
--MNI London Bureau; tel: +44 203-586-2225; email: les.commons@marketnews.com
[TOPICS: MFIBU$,M$E$$$,M$I$$$,M$X$$$,MC$$$$,MI$$$$,MX$$$$,MFX$$$,MGX$$$]
MNI London Bureau | +44 203-865-3812 | les.commons@marketnews.com

To read the full story

Close

Why MNI

MNI is the leading provider

of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.

Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.