Free Trial

MNI INSIGHT: BOE MPC Communications Compatible With Jan Cut

--BOE Enters Quiet Period With Only Carney, Externals Having Given Policy
Comments
--MPC's Haldane, Broadbent, Cunliffe Have Backed Rate Changes Before Without
Signalling Support
--"Coming Months" Phrase Used By Tenreyro Does Not Preclude Jan Move
By David Robinson
     LONDON (MNI) - The silence over a possible rate cut from four of the five
internal members on the nine strong Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee
does not tilt the scales against a move this month, MNI analysis of MPC members'
commentary shows.
     Three of those four internals have previously backed a rate change without
signalling support in the months ahead of the past two policy change meetings,
in November 2017 and August 2018. Deputy Governor Jon Cunliffe surprised by
voting for the August 2018 hike, for which Chief Economist Andy Haldane had also
first voted, without warning, in June that year. Deputy Governor Ben Broadbent,
who heads the Bank's monetary policy wing, has persistently offered at most
limited guidance, having declared his opposition to "spoon feeding" analysts and
market participants.
     Past experience also shows that the silence of the internals is compatible
with no change. Broadbent recommends looking at the data flow and seeking to
understand the MPC's reaction function.
     But two external MPC members voted for a cut at the BOE's December meeting,
and the other two have since said they are open to easing. The internals have
kept mum, and with the pre-meeting blackout starting on Monday, Jan. 20, they
will provide no further steers ahead of the policy announcement on Jan. 30.
     Deputy Governor Dave Ramsden did clearly signal he was likely to oppose the
November 2017 hike and support the August 2018 one, so it would be a break with
the past if he were to vote for a cut without first signalling it this month.
     Haldane appears to have offered no steer on policy in the three months
preceding the 2017 and 2018 hikes. Cunliffe did make pretty clear that he was
going to oppose the 2017 hike but was studiedly ambiguous in his public
commentary before the move in 2018.
     --EXTENDED BLACKOUT
     MPC communication ahead of this month's meeting has been constricted by the
Dec. 12 General Election, with the official electoral blackout period kicking in
on Nov. 6, before the November meeting's blackout had finished, preventing MPC
members doing the usual round of media appearances following the quarterly
forecast round.
     External MPC members Jonathan Haskel and Michael Saunders have both made
their policy stance clear by voting for easing at the November and December
meetings and making speeches this month setting out their reasoning.
     Their colleague Silvana Tenreyro said at a Resolution Foundation event on
Jan. 10 that "if uncertainty over the future trading arrangement or subdued
global growth continues to weigh on UK demand then my inclination is towards
voting for a cut in Bank Rate in the near term." When pushed on the timing, she
said "I am talking about the coming months."
     The "coming months" phrase appears to include this month's meeting. She
used it back in October 2017, telling the Treasury Select Committee that that if
the data evolved as expected she "would be minded to vote for a Bank Rate
increase in coming months" before voting for a hike the following month.
     BOE Governor Mark Carney made speeches to set out the contours of the MPC
debate on the MPC ahead of the two previous rate changes and he did so again
this month, floating arguments for and against a cut without coming down firmly
on one side or the other.
--MNI London Bureau; tel: +44 203-586-2223; email: david.robinson@marketnews.com
[TOPICS: M$B$$$,M$E$$$,MT$$$$,MX$$$$,M$$BE$]

To read the full story

Close

Why MNI

MNI is the leading provider

of intelligence and analysis on the Global Fixed Income, Foreign Exchange and Energy markets. We use an innovative combination of real-time analysis, deep fundamental research and journalism to provide unique and actionable insights for traders and investors. Our "All signal, no noise" approach drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, which is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.

Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.